Comments (24)

• 

  Aug 05, 2010 5:30 PM

  thatonedude says:

  beyonce. no one else has the requirements to be A TALENT JUDGE. plus the eye candy would be nice
• 

  Aug 05, 2010 9:32 AM

  AlbionGal says:

  None of these really, but if one of them gets it then it should be Paula. I want to hear about it when she shows up drunk or whatever the hell she used to do. Ellen needs to stick with comedy and her show, which I like. Tyra should stick with modeling and her shows too. Beyonce needs to stick with singing and dancing and no judging. Kathy needs to just continue to do whatever it is that she does.
• 

  Aug 05, 2010 12:54 AM

  ViewerTomcat says:

  i Cast my Vote for Beyonce.
• 

  Aug 04, 2010 12:35 AM

  rose69 says:

  Tyra Banks, Give me a break!! that woman has NO talent!
• 

  Aug 02, 2010 3:37 PM

  RAREDIAMOND49 says:

  Really American Idol used to be my show. It has gone down and need to bow out gracefully. There are too many "REALITY SHOWS" on that is not worth watching. People get a hold of something and run it in the hole. Time for some of these "REALITY SHOWS" to bow out.American Idol has always been my favorite.
• 

  Aug 02, 2010 3:34 PM

  RAREDIAMOND49 says:

  If someone was to replace Ellen I would like for it to be Paula Abdul. She's cool and down-to-earth. She's not "PHONEY".......
• 

  Jul 31, 2010 7:26 AM

  Esther says:

  This poll is soooooooooooo stupid!
• 

  Jul 31, 2010 3:17 AM

  snowdog01 says:

  I agree with SueBee No J. Lo PLEASE NO OR I am done with Idol. Paula, Randy, and Brett Michaels. Randy, Paula, and Gene Simmons. NO NEVER Kathy Griffin......... Paua, Randy, Elton John.....
• 

  Jul 30, 2010 10:26 PM

  TVjunkiemama says:

  Is there still such an audience out there that American Idol should still continue? What's the draw anymore? Beside Carrie Underwood and Kelly Clarkson, there's no real talent that has come away the winner. I stopped watching after Fantasia won.
• 

  Jul 30, 2010 6:47 PM

  ocirvinenp says:

  This show has had a good run and now that run is over American Idol should be canceled. Replacing jodges and swithcing people around as they are once again trying to do proves this show is over. Lights-ou American Idol.
• 

  Jul 30, 2010 6:02 PM

  breeorbree says:

  None of them, but, come on - Kathy Griffin as a choice????? She has been fired from so many jobs because of her mouth.
• 

  Jul 30, 2010 3:41 PM

  weeden84 says:

  Kinda sad Ellen decided to quit, never was a huge fan of Kara. I say Jennifer. I think she is a jack of all trades, and has perfected everything. Come on she played Salena!!! and was awsome. Also I think she seems like a wonderful person, and she is a good actress. Quit hatin ppl. Also they should have not let Paula go.
• 

  Jul 30, 2010 3:40 PM

  essence says:

  Bring back Paula.
• 

  Jul 30, 2010 3:07 PM

  mrcruzfl says:

  I believe this show is DONE and OVER
• 

  Jul 30, 2010 2:58 PM

  jodyshood says:

  Done Deal..This site is late......Kara D got axed and JLo is replacing Kara&Ellen while Steven Tyler from Aerosmith is taking over for Simon.....YIKES!!
• 

  Jul 30, 2010 2:39 PM

  sumpinfierce says:

  This show is over. @SueBee732 I understand where you're coming from with the J.Lo comment, but look at Paula: they have a very similar rise to fame (minus the movie roles on Paula's part) and I think it's a natural choice to fill her shoes. But once again, this show is over: Simon's gone, there's no reason to continue.
• 

  Jul 30, 2010 2:28 PM

  spunky44 says:

  HOW BOUT THE #1 DIVA IN THE MUSIC GAME FOR A MINUTE!!! BEYONCE BABY!! THERE SURE WOULD BE A LOT MORE PEOPLE TUNING IN!!!!
• 

  Jul 30, 2010 1:44 PM

  sallyec1 says:

  anyone but Kathy Yuck!
• 

  Jul 30, 2010 1:21 PM

  Mursci says:

  deestea said it best - I agree on all counts. Even on what she said about Kathy Griffin - they put HER on and I'm GONE!
• 

  Jul 30, 2010 1:19 PM

  kidiekat says:

  I do not like Tyra, Kathy is not a singer, and Beyonce doesn't belong there. I agree with Brenkis Kara was too into herself I am glad if they dumped her. She is the one that started Idol on it's tumble. I like Ellen but her forte is comedy not music. I have to give her credit for trying though. Jennifer Lopez? NO WAY. She needs to find something and perfect it. Quit scrambling into everything.
• 

  Jul 30, 2010 1:17 PM

  deestea says:

  Kathy Griffin? That's a joke right? If that were to happen, I can honestly say that I would never watch AI again. Tyra Banks? Another joke right? Leave her to her America's Top Model. Either bring back Paula or find somebody with a background in singing so the contestants can be judged fairly!
• 

  Jul 30, 2010 1:14 PM

  Brenkis says:

  Hopefully what I read is right! They dumped Kara, too! Yay, what a great day for Idol! Didn't like either one of them. Ellen was too wishy/washy and Kara had to "sing" everything to let them know what they SHOULD sound like! Gag me! Also, I can't stand her buggy eyes!
• 

  Jul 30, 2010 1:06 PM

  SueBee732 says:

  I do NOT want Jennifer Lopez to be an Idol judge!! She's a jack of all trades and master of none, especially singing! I don't think she's a good singer and she should not be judging anyone.
• 

  Jul 30, 2010 12:23 PM

  MIAMIFLORIDA says:

  Well, it would not let me vote, so I will use a write-in ballot for Paula!!!